On
April 13th SB 724 passed out of committee with bipartisan
support on a vote of 10-0. To see the votes,
click
here.
The
bill, which was introduced by California State Senator Ben
Allen in February, affirms and strengthens the right to
counsel for conservatees and proposed conservatees. While the
bill may have been inspired by a judge's refusal to allow
Britney Spears to have her attorney of choice, others have
experienced the same denial of counsel, such as 84 year-old
Theresa Jankowski in Los Angeles or 24 year-old Elizabeth H.
in Solano.
Originally,
the bill specified that if a conservatee or proposed
conservatee expresses any preference for a particular attorney
to represent them, the court shall allow it even if the
attorney is not on the court's list of approved
attorneys. Senator Allen has amended the bill to provide
additional
protections.
Courts
in Sacramento and elsewhere will no longer be able to deprive
proposed conservatees of the right to counsel
altogether. If they don't have an attorney of choice,
the court must appoint
one to represent them. Further, any ambiguity in the
role of counsel will be removed. The amended bill says
that such attorneys shall act as
a zealous
advocate for the
client. No more acting as a "best interests" attorney or
de-facto investigator for the court. Finally, the bill
will require appellate courts to appoint counsel for
conservatees whose cases come before them in appeals or writ
proceedings. No more situations where a conservatee like
Catherine Dubro was treated as though she did not exist, even
though she was a respondent in an appellate proceeding where
tens of thousands of dollars of her assets were at
stake.
Spectrum
Institute sent a letter to the Senate Judiciary Committee of
the California Legislature in support of SB 724 which provided
reference materials and legal precedents that support each of
the four major components of the right to counsel protections
in the bill. For a copy of the
letter, click
here.
The National Coalition on the Civil Right to Counsel also sent
of letter of support which can be read here.
While
the amended bill does not contain all of the elements that
Spectrum Institute would have liked -- such as authorizing the
Judicial Council to develop performance standards for
appointed attorneys in conservatorship proceedings, it is a
major advancement for the right to counsel in
California. For that Senator Allen should be
commended. The bill will be heard on May 3, 2021 in the
Senate Appropriations Committee. For a copy of the amended
bill, click
here. |